Monday, 28 January 2008

Letter from Bryan Sanderson

On Thursday the NRSSG received a letter from Rock Chairman Bryan Sanderson, responding to a number of points we raised in the aftermath of the recent EGM.

NRSSG founder Robin Ashby writes:
They're not necessarily great answers, but any communication is better than none. You'll have seen from my comments elsewhere that I was pleased at the spirit of the EGM and hope that we can have a new sense of common purpose going forward.

We reproduce the text of Mr Sanderson's response below:

Our question: The company has appointed Georgeson to ring shareholders at home, even though they have made clear on the calling notice what the directors position was. Why have you done that and how much money has it cost?
Bryan Sanderson: The Company thought it important that, as far as possible, the vote at the EGM represented the views of all shareholders so was keen to encourage all shareholders to vote and to help them to do so. The Company hired Georgeson because it has the resources and expertise necessary to approach shareholders, particularly the very large number of small shareholders, to encourage them to vote and give them opportunity to ask questions about the voting process. I do not think it is appropriate to disclose the amount that the Company paid Georgeson, not least because it is a confidential commercial arrangement between them and the Company, however, I can disclose that they were paid negotiated market rates which the Company wholly appropriate. In the context of the overall costs of the EGM, which you will recall was convened at the behest of two of our shareholders, the amount was small.

Our question: Will the strategic review safeguard the interests of the Northern Rock Foundation?
Bryan Sanderson: The Company is very proud of our work with the Foundation and would like to see it continue in the future. However, any decision concerning the Company's support of the Foundation must await the outcome of the strategic review process (SRP). As I stressed at the EGM -- and as the Company has announced on several occasions since October -- the SRP is expected to be completed in February. In the meantime, pending the outcome of the SRP, the Foundation's Trustees have indicated they have funds set aside to meet all of the Foundation's outstanding commitments and are keeping their priorities and budgets under review. We are encouraged by the apparent desire of HM Government disclosed in its recent announcement that the good work of the Foundation continues in all circumstances.

Our question: Why was there a significant delay in entering substantive negations with the Olivant consortium and what is the current state of these negotiations?
Bryan Sanderson: The Company's discussions with Olivant concerning its proposal were able to progress, and Olivant was able to become fully involved in the SRP, as soon as it decided to sign the form of the non-disclosure agreement that all other interested parties had signed. They did so some time after the Virgin Consortium and other interested parties had signed their non-disclosure agreements in substantially the same terms. Because of its delay in doing so, Olivant was initially behind some other interested parties but has caught up now as a result of the efforts it and we have made. Olivant is now fully engaged in the process and we are working closely with them to assist them in progressing their proposal.

Our question: How much do you expect to have to pay all the consultants and advisors supporting the strategic review?
Bryan Sanderson: As you know, the SRP is ongoing and it is therefore impossible to predict the total cost of all consultants and advisors supporting the process. I can tell you that the Company is paying its advisers negotiated market rates that it considers wholly appropriate. I would expect to be able to give you a more accurate and up-to-date figure in the documentation sent to shareholders at the time we will seek approval of the outcome of the SRP.

Our question: Chairman, will you undertake to keep the shareholders better informed about the strategic review as it proceeds?
Bryan Sanderson: As I explained at the EGM, the Company is significantly constrained by confidentiality and other legal requirements in relation to the information it is able to provide shareholders about the SRP. We are constantly monitoring our ability to provide you with information concerning the SRP and will continue to announce developments if and when we are legally permitted to do so. As we have said, as things stand currently, we expect to provide full details to shareholders when we come to them for approval of the outcome of the SRP.

Our question: Has Northern Rock approach the European Central Bank for financial support as was recently suggested by an MEP?
Bryan Sanderson: Given the Company's eligible collateral it would not have been possible to secure any meaningful advance from the European Central Bank before October 2007 and even that option is no longer possible given the terms of the Bank of England facility.


Northern Rock media round-up no. 2

In Thursday's Times (24 January 2008), Ann Trenemann wrote in her parliamentary sketch of PMQs:

As David Cameron arose and started shouting about Northern Rock, the PM flashed another inappropriate smile. Oh, how he must yearn for his first-class cabin at times like this: his capsule bed, his little pyjama outfit, his fluffy socks and his light reading ( War and Peace in the original Russian).

With reluctance, he dragged himself back to PMQs and the wild-eyed man opposite demanding to know how much taxpayers’ money had been invested in Northern Rock. “If the bonds aren’t paid back and if Northern Rock fails to meet its obligations, what is the total exposure? How much?” demanded Mr Cameron.

The PM wouldn’t say. “It is our intention to get the taxpayer the best deal, their money back and to make a profit!”

Well, snapped David Cameron, the real answer was £55 billion and he accused the PM of acting like Del Boy.

The PM was pained. Del Boy? What was that? A horse? A pineapple? Was it related to kebabs? The world must be very confusing at times for our Prime Minister. Mr Cameron shouted: “This is a sub-prime deal from a sub-prime minister!”

This economic taunt hurt, not least because Mr Brown understood it, and the slug-fest began in earnest, a sort of Rocky VI in suits though, actually, I guess that would be Northern Rocky VI. The PM kept saying that the economy was stable, Mr Cameron the opposite. “Isn’t this Northern Rock deal just damaging, dodgy extra debt from a failed Prime Minister?” he screamed.


On Saturday, the Newcastle Journal, reporting on the House of Commons Treasury Committee's report, The run on the Rock, quoted NRSSG founder Robin Ashby:
Last night Robin Ashby, of the Northern Rock Small Shareholders Group, said: “I welcome this report by the Court of Parliament. It brings rapidly to the attention of the authorities their own ‘Contributory Negligence’ in the collapse of Northern Rock and is justification, if any further were needed, in the continuing role of the Government and taxpayer in ensuring that the bank is able to restructure itself and go forward.

On Sunday, writing in the Observer, Catherine Bennett asked (of Richard Branson), 'Why is anyone fooled by the smile of this slick operator?' She concludes:
Branson's Screw It, Let's Do It philosophy may be more persuasive than it looks. Once Rophynol has been ruled out, and, given Mrs Brown's presence, undressed girls ('I believe in using sex appeal to promote the Virgin image'), we may have to accept that nothing more than crass self-promotion has convinced Brown, one of the most sanctimonious leaders in political history, that an act of collective altruism in favour of Branson and his financiers would be fairer, and more popular with taxpayers, than nationalisation. Unless he's just keen on space. A lot of boys are.

UKSA Northern Rock Update 19

The latest Northern Rock update from the UK Shareholders Association is now available online, in PDF format, at:
http://www.uksa.org.uk/NorthernRock_Update_19.pdf

Earlier Northern Rock bulletins from the UKSA can also be found on the UKSA website.

Friday, 25 January 2008

Northern Rock media round-up no. 1

Here's our selection of the Northern Rock media coverage in the past week or so:

In 'Northern Rock shareholders welcome plan' (22/01/08), the Financial Times reported that Rock shareholders welcomed government plans as "increasing the chances of an indepdendent, commercially viable future". It quotes NRSSG founder Robin Ashby reacting to the proposals:
"It gives a platform for those people who have some realistic chance of putting together rescue plans in a timely fashion," said Mr Ashby.

On 21/01/08, the Daily Mail reported on accusations of a "cosy stitch-up" between Gordon Brown and Sir Richard Branson. The Prime Minister has admitted he discussed the deal with Sir Richard while in China earlier this week.

Sunday's Observer (20/01/08) asked "how is the Geordie bravado holding up in the face of dire economic - and footballing - circumstance?"
Small investor Robin Ashby bought his shares in Northern Rock to show his support for the local economy. 'It is one of only two big quoted companies based in the north east,' he says. It is also, he adds, 'fantastically' important to the area - about 3,500 of its 6,300 employees are based in Newcastle and a further 1,500 in nearby Sunderland. Northern Rock is one of the few businesses employing significant numbers of graduate trainees - many of its senior management, including former chief executive Adam Applegarth, joined the company that way. Its charita ble foundation is a 'significant player' in local projects; and, of course, its name is emblazoned on the shirts of Newcastle's football team.

Ashby's loyalty prevented him from selling out last August, when the first hints emerged that its business could be affected by the sub-prime crisis. He remained faithful even when the repercussions from bad lending in the US sent Northern Rock to the Bank of England for help and savers queued to withdraw their money.
Like the rest of the Rock's shareholders, large and small, he hopes that loyalty will be repaid with a sale of the bank to one of the two private-sector bidders. But the odds on some form of nationalisation remain significant, for all last week's assurances by Alistair Darling and Gordon Brown that a private-sector solution remains the preferred course.

Thursday, 24 January 2008

Wanted: Your Northern Rock memories

Financial journalist Richard Tomlinson is writing an article about Northern Rock, going back to its days as a building society. He'd like to talk to or meet NRSSG members and Rock account-holders, not just about the present situation but also about the history of the bank-cum-building-society.
He'll be in Newcastle on Thursday 24 January and Friday 25 January. If you've got the time to talk to him, and think you might be able to help him, let us know (melanie@north-house.com) and we'll pass the message on.