Wednesday, 9 December 2009
Northern Rock investors will not get compensation
Thousands of Northern Rock investors have suffered a setback in their claims for compensation following the nationalisation of the Newcastle-based lender nearly two years ago after the independent valuer concluded that there was "no value" in the bank's shares.
After receiving "several thousand" responses, the independent valuer Andrew Caldwell published a consultation document in which he concludes that shareholders should receive "no compensation".
His pronouncements came as the government said the nationalised lender could be split in two – in to a "good" and "bad" bank – on 1 January. However, government sources warned that hopes that the "good" part of the bank could be sold before an election were rapidly fading.
The division of the bank, which has been sanctioned by Europe, will have implications for mortgage customers of Northern Rock as some customers will be placed into the "bad" bank.
The Treasury select committee of MPs, which yesterday signalled it would begin a new inquiry into why some banks were deemed "too big to fail", is also expected to weigh the pros and cons of Northern Rock being turned back into a mutual – a status it held before 1997.
Responding to a campaign at Westminster, partly organised by the Co-operative Party and which has seen 100 MPs sign a parliamentary motion jointly calling for the bank to be remutualised, the committee will look at the "relationship between size and risk, and business model (including mutual models) and risk".
The investigation into whether shareholders should be compensated has taken longer than expected, Caldwell, a partner at accountants BDO Stoy Hayward, admitted. He encountered difficulties in obtaining the information he needed – and had been promised – when he was appointed by the Treasury 14 months ago. He did not receive some of the information until last month, further delaying the publication of today's consultation document. His report has cost £4.5m.
But shareholders, led by hedge fund manager Jon Wood, who have demanded compensation from the government and are determined to carry on their fight and are ready to take their claim to the European court of human rights in Strasbourg.
Wood, who is awaiting a decision from Britain's new supreme court about whether the methodology used by Caldwell can be challenged, said: "I do really think we'll get justice in the end."
Under the terms of his appointment, Caldwell based his calculation on the lender being in administration and no longer "a going concern" after all assistance from the Bank of England and the Treasury had been withdrawn.
He calculated how much money Northern Rock would have had left for shareholders after it had repaid the £25bn loan from the Bank of England, granted in September 2007 when it experienced funding difficulties during the credit crunch.
He concluded that it was "unlikely" Northern Rock could have been sold in its entirety and therefore searched for any assets the lender could have sold to raise the necessary funds. Following a complex analysis, he concluded that the lender would actually have had no money left after repaying the loan and would have been "in a deficit" of £5.7bn.
However, Wood and other shareholders have argued that the basis for the review for compensation should have assumed that the lender was still a "going concern" when it was nationalised. If this had been the case, shares in Northern Rock might have been valued at £4, Wood argued.
Friday, 23 October 2009
Northern Rock to be dismembered, sold?
He stressed that there had always been value in the bank, and this plan proves that to be the case. This should be recognised in the compensation to be paid for the shares which were confiscated from us. The so-called "impaired assets" could well prove to be profitable in the long term if the Government doesn't panic for short term political reasons.
Thursday, 1 October 2009
Applegarth and Apollo
Robin commented:
"This is extraordinary. Mr Applegarth's judgement, and therefore Apollo's in taking him on, must be very much in question after the events of 2007.
"The mechanism for him doing the job can be seen as trying to get round FSA rules, which, if the case, is reprehensible.
"What are these people trying to achieve? The Government, Northern Rock, and their circus of highly paid advisers must have gone to the outermost edges of these dodgy deals, and must make that information available as part of any due diligence. If Applegarth has any insider knowledge that would help a buyer, I would have expected him to make that known to Northern Rock's team in return for his mega payoff.
"Some humility, and an apology to all those like our members who he has helped impoverish, wouldn't go amiss before he takes any new job."
Tuesday, 4 August 2009
Northern Rock : Half year loss of £724.2m
Northern Rock has reported a loss of £724.2m for the first six months of 2009, compared with a loss of £585.4m in the first half of last year.
The nationalised bank said that 3.92% of its mortgage loans were more than three months in arrears, well above the national average of 2.39%.
It currently owes the government £10.9bn, but is waiting for European regulatory clearance for more funding.
Northern Rock was nationalised in February 2008.
It had to be bailed out by taxpayers in 2007, when its model of borrowing short-term funds from wholesale markets to lend to mortgage borrowers was hit by the credit crunch.
BBC business editor Robert Peston said that there were tentative signs that Northern Rock may be over the worst.
But he added that its mortgages are continuing to go bad at an alarming rate and a faster rate than most of its rivals.
The bank said the total value of all of its loans had fallen by £602.2m in the first six months of the year.
Additional funding
Northern Rock is in the process of splitting itself into two companies, one of which will hold savers' money and be responsible for new lending, while the other will hold many of the existing loans and be responsible for paying back loans to the government.
Have Your Say
J Shaw, Bradford
Once the restructuring has been completed, the Treasury will provide additional funding if the European Commission agrees to allow the plan.
Chief executive Gary Hoffman told reporters he was making "good progress" in discussions with the Commission and expected to receive clearance in the autumn.
Earlier in the year, Northern Rock announced a change to its strategy, which has meant that it has reduced the priority of repaying its loans to the government and instead has tried to increase the amount of money it is lending.
But it has warned it is unlikely to meet its target of £5bn of new lending for this year and is more likely to hit a figure of £4bn.
Mortgage demand
Mr Hoffman said that the target would be missed, because it was constrained by not yet having received state aid clearance from Europe.
But he added that there would have been demand for the extra money if it had been available and said applications for Northern Rock mortgages had doubled in the second quarter of the year, compared with the first three months of the year.
In addition to reporting statutory losses, Northern Rock also released an underlying figure, which it said gave a better reflection of the state of the business.
The underlying loss fell to £269.6m for the six months to 30 June, compared with £443.3m for the same period of 2008.
The underlying figure excludes a £156.4m rebate that it will receive if it gets state aid clearance from the European Commission.
It also excludes what it calls a volatility charge of £298.2m on the way it accounts for the value of certain assets.
Wednesday, 29 July 2009
Give us back our shares!
In his view, this was by no means the end of the line. He would expect the case to go next to the new Supreme Court (which is the Judicial Committee of the House of Lords until 31 July) and if the shareholders lose there, perhaps even to the European Court of Human Rights.
(The parties to the case are the two biggest shareholders, RAB and SRM Global, and a few selected small shareholders working with the UK Shareholders Association.)
Once the legal challenge is resolved, the valuer can get on with his wrok. But it is part of the contention that the rules have been so rigged by the Government that they are wqasting money to employ him and might just as well be honest and say “we've taken your shares and we're going to give you nowt”
The view that he expressed was that the small shareholders for whom NRSSG speaks don't want derisory compensation, they want fairness. The big banks weren't nationalised. The Government stood behind them while they tried to launch rights issues which the Government underwrote. So it ended up with a dominant shareholding. In the case of Northern Rock, it could easily have done the same thing. Indeed, it has injected £3 billion as shares.
We might have been diluted to a very large extent, but we'd still have been shareholders in our company and could share in any upside – which obviously the Government expects, because it's planning to sell Northern Rock back to the private sector as soon as it can.
Clearly all this will be going on until the General Election next year, when I expect former shareholders will be reminded about the theft of their shares, and will hold politicians seeking their vote to account.
There's an easy way for them to get out of this situation – give us back our shares!